|
|
Free speech law will affect SBS Save Our SBS, Tuesday, 1 April, 2014
Last month the Attorney General, Senator George Brandis, QC, said, “People do have a right to be bigots you know. In a free country people do have rights to say things that other people find offensive or insulting or bigoted.” He was defending the Abbott Government’s proposed repeal of section 18C of the Racial Discrimination Act 1975 in the Freedom of Speech Bill 2014.
Section 18C currently makes it “unlawful for a person to . . . offend, insult, humiliate or intimidate another person or a group of people . . . because of the race, colour or national or ethnic origin”, except in private. The government wants to remove these provisions saying ‘they unreasonably limit free speech.’
However the Chair of the Federation of Ethnic Communities’ Councils of Australia (FECCA), Joe Caputo, said,
Offend, insult and humiliate would be replaced with “vilify” complemented by “intimidate”, both defined very narrowly. The changes would introduce a community test to assess whether an act would constitute vilification or intimidation. Apart from lacking definitional clarity, the test in itself is discriminatory as it implies that a particular group within the Australian community is somehow unequal to ordinary reasonable members of the Australian community.
On 20 March, FECCA issued a statement that said,
FECCA is deeply concerned by the Federal Government’s mooted changes to the racial vilification protections in the Racial Discrimination Act.
Last December more than 150 leading community organisations wrote to the Attorney-General urging him not to repeal the racial vilification provisions.
An exposure draft of the changes show that section 18C would be repealed as well as 18B, 18D and 18E. They define the circumstances of an unlawful act when based on race, colour or national or ethnic origin when offending, insulting, humiliating or intimidating – subject to exemptions of academic, artistic or scientific purpose and matters in the public interest or if a fair and accurate report or fair comment is made as an expression of a genuine belief held by the person making the comment. Under the draft, these would be repealed but it would be illegal to vilify or intimidate a person due to their race, colour or ethnicity, however the test for that would be based on “the standards of an ordinary reasonable member of the Australian community, not by the standards of any particular group within the Australian community.”
A person who was the subject of racially offensive insults in public, for example on a bus, would not be protected under the proposed changes in law, and if intimidated, they would need to demonstrate cause for fear of physical harm. If the victim felt vilified, feelings alone would be irrelevant. It would need to be established that the insults incited hatred against the person — according to ordinary members of the public — not the distressed victim. Sympathy from onlookers on the bus, may be regarded as evidence that hatred had not occurred.
The exposure draft reveals it would not be unlawful to intimidate or vilify anyone due to “words, sounds, images or writing spoken, broadcast, published or otherwise communicated in the course of participating in the public discussion of any political, social, cultural, religious, artistic, academic or scientific matter.”
Such broad exclusions would seem to have great relevance to most broadcasters, but SBS in particular, where it might be possible for someone from one ethnic community to incite prejudice against another without recrimination. Potentially SBS may not legally be able to have policies in place to prevent this.
As a loyal supporter of the nation’s multiethnic broadcaster with its rightful policy of social cohesion — SBS — Save Our SBS concurs with that expressed by FECCA, being-
strong opposition to weakening the provisions that are critical in eliminating intolerance in Australia’s culturally diverse society through effective protections of vulnerable groups.
The government has invited public submissions from stakeholders to the proposed changes to the Racial Discrimination Act. The closing date for submissions is 30 April, emailed to s18cconsultation@ag.gov.au
Comments are closed.
|
Recent
-
SBS closes World News channel
Friday, 18 September, 2026
-
Save Our SBS opposes Hanson’s policy to close SBS and end multiculturalism
Saturday, 20 June, 2026
-
Placing ads on SBS explained – for dummies and everyone else!
Thursday, 1 January, 2026
-
SBS Natural Program Breaks Review
Saturday, 1 February, 2025
-
SBS promises “uninterrupted viewing” this year
Monday, 1 January, 2024
-
Securing Public Funding to Support SBS Independence
Thursday, 31 August, 2023
-
SBS funding
Thursday, 11 May, 2023
-
SBS to be funded 5-yearly
Tuesday, 25 October, 2022
-
SBS: Connecting with the Oldest Continuing Culture
Saturday, 11 June, 2022
-
Uluru Statement from the Heart translated by SBS into more than 20 Aboriginal languages and 60+ other languages
Sunday, 29 May, 2022
-
Compelling programs on SBS in 2022
Monday, 7 March, 2022
-
SBS pioneer Andy Lloyd-James dies
Monday, 28 February, 2022
-
SBS continues to alienate and betray its audience
Wednesday, 12 January, 2022
-
SBS WorldWatch new channel this year
Saturday, 1 January, 2022
-
End In-Program Ads On SBS
Tuesday, 12 October, 2021
-
SBS live COVID-19 updates in multiple languages
Monday, 23 August, 2021
-
NAIDOC returns to SBS
Sunday, 4 July, 2021
-
See What You Made Me Do
Wednesday, 5 May, 2021
-
Email SBS board of directors & politicians to #GetExcessiveCommercialBreaksOffSBS
Tuesday, 2 February, 2021
-
Easy English news
Monday, 18 January, 2021
-
2021 slate: This year’s line-up
Friday, 1 January, 2021
-
THREE QUESTION POLL results
Thursday, 1 October, 2020
-
Get Excessive Commercial Breaks Off SBS
Sunday, 27 September, 2020
-
SBS hour logged with 50 percent more ads than allowed
Tuesday, 1 September, 2020
-
Poll: overwhelming support for fully-funded multicultural, multiethnic, and Indigenous programs for children on SBS but with advertising restrictions
Tuesday, 21 July, 2020
-
New SBS Chair: familiar face
Thursday, 9 July, 2020
-
Two question poll: SBS children’s TV
Friday, 12 June, 2020
-
Australian content and children’s TV on SBS — a submission to the Supporting Australian stories on our screens–Options paper
Friday, 12 June, 2020
-
Get gambling off SBS
Friday, 8 May, 2020
-
SBS multilingual coronavirus portal
Thursday, 26 March, 2020
-
The economic reason to remove in-program advertising on SBS
Wednesday, 16 October, 2019
-
How does learning a language make a world of difference to you?
Monday, 26 August, 2019
-
SBS World Movies channel a natural fit for SBS
Wednesday, 12 June, 2019
-
New minister for SBS
Wednesday, 29 May, 2019
-
Know what you’re voting for!
Monday, 13 May, 2019
-
SBS World Movies channel
Monday, 6 May, 2019
-
Farewell Darce Cassidy
Thursday, 2 May, 2019
-
New TV channel proposed with more foreign language content and commercially less intrusive than current SBS channels
Monday, 22 April, 2019
-
Budget for SBS not brilliant
Tuesday, 2 April, 2019
-
SBS & friends say ‘fully-fund Australian content on SBS’ senate committee told
Friday, 16 November, 2018
-
SBS appoints new MD
Friday, 19 October, 2018
-
SBS National Languages Competition 2018
Monday, 15 October, 2018
-
Are you the next SBS Managing Director?
Tuesday, 4 September, 2018
-
SBS boss steps down
Tuesday, 17 July, 2018
-
Viewers say ‘hand back our SBS without ads’ competitive neutrality inquiry
Monday, 2 July, 2018
-
Attaining a level playing field: SBS commercial
Monday, 2 July, 2018
-
Does SBS encroach in the commercial sphere?
Monday, 14 May, 2018
-
Budget returns funds to SBS over two years
Tuesday, 8 May, 2018
-
Competitive neutrality inquiry into the ABC and SBS begins
Thursday, 29 March, 2018
-
Law to limit gambling ads but Labor wants SBS exempted
Saturday, 24 March, 2018
-
Australian content on SBS
Wednesday, 14 February, 2018
-
What’s on SBS this year
Monday, 1 January, 2018
-
The Mosque Next Door
Sunday, 5 November, 2017
-
Pollies want better deal for SBS
Tuesday, 24 October, 2017
-
Sunshine: compelling drama tells life of South Sudanese in Australia
Thursday, 12 October, 2017
-
New SBS radio line-up soon
Monday, 25 September, 2017
-
SBS aim to triple Oz content forum told
Saturday, 1 July, 2017
-
SBS cannot be privatised: Michael Ebeid explains
Thursday, 1 June, 2017
-
Government backs down on SBS advertising Bill
Thursday, 18 May, 2017
-
Mary Kostakidis speaks out against government Bill to increase SBS advertising
Saturday, 6 May, 2017
-
Advertising bill will manoeuvre SBS away from its Charter obligations
Saturday, 6 May, 2017
-
Preserve our media diversity: Don’t turn SBS into Australia’s fourth commercial TV network
Saturday, 6 May, 2017
-
National survey shows SBS viewers do not want gambling ads and reject government’s SBS commercialisation policy
Wednesday, 26 April, 2017
-
Précis of Survey 2017 about SBS
Wednesday, 26 April, 2017
-
SURVEY: Is SBS doing it right?
Saturday, 1 April, 2017
-
Save Our SBS welcomes new SBS Chairman
Tuesday, 14 February, 2017
-
Feedback to the SBS radio review 2016
Saturday, 10 December, 2016
-
SBS to double primetime advertising if bill passes
Tuesday, 18 October, 2016
-
Identity theft or giving up on Charter: how the ramping up of commercialism has weakened SBS a decade on
Saturday, 1 October, 2016
-
Minister asked to limit gambling ads on SBS
Thursday, 1 September, 2016
-
Gambling ads ought have no place on SBS
Thursday, 21 July, 2016
-
What will the Parties do with SBS after the election?
Monday, 20 June, 2016
-
SBS funding business as usual
Tuesday, 3 May, 2016
-
SBS to focus on its special Charter
Friday, 8 April, 2016
-
New SBS radio station: Arabic24
Monday, 7 March, 2016
-
Why the proposed takeover of SBS failed
Thursday, 3 March, 2016
-
Why the ABC wants to gobble SBS, not save it
Wednesday, 24 February, 2016
-
Don’t merge the ABC and SBS
Tuesday, 23 February, 2016
-
SBS a remarkable institution, part of Australia’s multicultural success
Thursday, 18 February, 2016
-
Government asked to increase SBS funding tied to charter compliance by a reduction in commercial breaks
Friday, 5 February, 2016
-
Pre-Budget Submission 2016: The SBS Community View
Friday, 5 February, 2016
-
Eclectic programming this year on SBS
Friday, 1 January, 2016
-
MYEFO grants partial restoration in SBS funding
Tuesday, 15 December, 2015
-
Parents and teachers to join the fight to protect and enhance the ABC and SBS
Tuesday, 10 November, 2015
-
SBS foodie channel soon to premiere
Thursday, 22 October, 2015
-
SBS cooking channel created for commercial return
Sunday, 4 October, 2015
-
Senator Mitch Fifield: Communications & Arts Minister
Monday, 21 September, 2015
-
Abbott’s broken SBS promise two years on
Sunday, 6 September, 2015
-
Disconnect Foxtel, don’t sack SBS staff
Friday, 26 June, 2015
-
Save Our SBS and supporters thank senators for saving SBS from itself
Wednesday, 24 June, 2015
-
62,000 sign petition opposing more ads on SBS
Tuesday, 2 June, 2015
-
Senate told of SBS hush plan to double ads before government cuts were announced
Monday, 25 May, 2015
-
Unacceptable coercion: SBS
Thursday, 23 April, 2015
-
The commercialisation of SBS versus efficiency
Tuesday, 21 April, 2015
-
Government wants to fully commercialise SBS with new law
Tuesday, 24 March, 2015
-
Commercialising SBS by stealth
Monday, 9 March, 2015
-
Preserve its Integrity! Don’t Increase Advertising on SBS
Wednesday, 14 January, 2015
-
Why SBS should not be further commercialised
Wednesday, 14 January, 2015
-
Petition opposes more ads
Wednesday, 14 January, 2015
-
Why more ads will be bad for SBS
Saturday, 10 January, 2015
|
Free speech law will affect SBS
Section 18C currently makes it “unlawful for a person to . . . offend, insult, humiliate or intimidate another person or a group of people . . . because of the race, colour or national or ethnic origin”, except in private. The government wants to remove these provisions saying ‘they unreasonably limit free speech.’
However the Chair of the Federation of Ethnic Communities’ Councils of Australia (FECCA), Joe Caputo, said,
On 20 March, FECCA issued a statement that said,
Last December more than 150 leading community organisations wrote to the Attorney-General urging him not to repeal the racial vilification provisions.
An exposure draft of the changes show that section 18C would be repealed as well as 18B, 18D and 18E. They define the circumstances of an unlawful act when based on race, colour or national or ethnic origin when offending, insulting, humiliating or intimidating – subject to exemptions of academic, artistic or scientific purpose and matters in the public interest or if a fair and accurate report or fair comment is made as an expression of a genuine belief held by the person making the comment. Under the draft, these would be repealed but it would be illegal to vilify or intimidate a person due to their race, colour or ethnicity, however the test for that would be based on “the standards of an ordinary reasonable member of the Australian community, not by the standards of any particular group within the Australian community.”
A person who was the subject of racially offensive insults in public, for example on a bus, would not be protected under the proposed changes in law, and if intimidated, they would need to demonstrate cause for fear of physical harm. If the victim felt vilified, feelings alone would be irrelevant. It would need to be established that the insults incited hatred against the person — according to ordinary members of the public — not the distressed victim. Sympathy from onlookers on the bus, may be regarded as evidence that hatred had not occurred.
The exposure draft reveals it would not be unlawful to intimidate or vilify anyone due to “words, sounds, images or writing spoken, broadcast, published or otherwise communicated in the course of participating in the public discussion of any political, social, cultural, religious, artistic, academic or scientific matter.”
Such broad exclusions would seem to have great relevance to most broadcasters, but SBS in particular, where it might be possible for someone from one ethnic community to incite prejudice against another without recrimination. Potentially SBS may not legally be able to have policies in place to prevent this.
As a loyal supporter of the nation’s multiethnic broadcaster with its rightful policy of social cohesion — SBS — Save Our SBS concurs with that expressed by FECCA, being-
The government has invited public submissions from stakeholders to the proposed changes to the Racial Discrimination Act. The closing date for submissions is 30 April, emailed to s18cconsultation@ag.gov.au